11 Oprah's Book Club Picks That Give Off Hallmark Channel Movie Vibes

Add Women on Google:

We may receive a commission on purchases made from links.

Oprah Winfrey isn't exactly known for choosing easy, breezy romantic books for her reading recommendations. In fact, if Oprah's Book Club's top 15 picks (so far) are anything to go by, the former talk show host mainly gravitates toward hard-hitting, often gritty, and sometimes dark books that pack a real emotional punch and get readers thinking. But that doesn't mean it's all doom and gloom on Winfrey's book shelf. There are a small handful of Winfrey's recs that are on the lighter side, so much so they give us cheesy (in a good way) and uplifting Hallmark Channel movie vibes.

To give you all the cozyness you'd expect from a heartwarming Hallmark offering, we scoured Oprah's Book Club's more than three decades of reccomendations and picked out the ones we believe could work as a Hallmark movie. We also included novels from Oprah Daily's collection of the Best Christmas Books to Snuggle up With This Holiday Season, as the Hallmark Channel is notorious for its festive offerings. From the likes of "Dream State" by Eric Puchner to "Open House" by Elizabeth Berg, these are the Winfrey-approved novels (presented in no particular order) to reach for when you're looking for a pick me up, plus the Hallmark movies they remind us of.

An American Marriage by Tayari Jones

What would you do if a romance blossomed with a long time friend while your partner is in prison? That's Celestial's reality in the dramatic fictional story "An American Marriage" by Tayari Jones. She finds solace with Andre, but when her husband Roy is unexpectedly set free and returns home, Celestial and Andre's life together is thrown into turmoil. The book, Oprah's Book Club's 78th pick, has classic Hallmark-level drama as Celestial finds herself torn between two lovers.

On Goodreads, multiple reviewers noted the book has a Hallmark-esque ending. This contemporary fiction is one of the best romance picks from Oprah's Book Club and gives us "A Christmas Detour" vibes, but with a grittier edge. Both the book and the movie deal with women in relationships who, due to circumstances out of their control, contemplate their future with another man. "You'll come away with greater empathy and understanding but even if you don't, it's just a really great read," Oprah Winfrey said of the novel. "It's the perfect book to read along with a friend or family member. You're going to want to have someone else reading it because it's so juicy," she added.

One Day in December by Josie Silver

In "One Day in December" by Josie Silver, a heartwarming Christmas book that will leave you feeling warm and cozy, Laurie is introduced to her best friend Sarah's new boyfriend. But her jaw drops when she realizes she's seen this man before. Several months earlier, pessimistic Laurie experienced love at first sight with a man she saw while on the bus. Though they never met, she was so convinced he was the one, and has been searching all over London for him ever since. The problem is now that he's right in front of her, he's on the arm of her bestie. This book spans a decade and dives into the dynamic between the trio as Laurie faces the consequences of not coming clean about her feelings.

The romantic holiday novel, which was also chosen by Oprah Winfrey's friend Reese Witherspoon for Reese's Book Club, has all the makings of a festive Hallmark classic. The premise is somewhat similar to the channel's "From Friend to Fiancé," in which a woman is forced to push down her feelings for a love interest because he's with someone else. "One Day in December" won't leave you out in the cold though, as it has an emotional but satisfying ending like we'd expect from the Hallmark Channel, according to Goodreads reviewers.

Royal Holiday by Jasmine Guillory

Vivian Forest takes a trip to England in "Royal Holiday" by Jasmine Guillory, where she meets handsome private secretary to the royals, Malcolm Hudson. But Vivian has more than just sightseeing to write about on a postcard home, because she sparks up a romance with the well-spoken Brit who rubs shoulders with the royal family on the daily. Both know their fling can't last with the Atlantic Ocean separating them, so they decide they'll have their fun but go their separate ways on New Year's Day. With heaps of holiday coziness, an irresistible love story, and royals aplenty, this romantic novel screams Hallmark. True to the genre, Vivian and Malcolm's romance may just go on well beyond when the credits roll (or the pages end, in this case).

The light, romantic novel is perfect for those who loved Hallmark's "Fit For A Prince," which tells a similar story of a women who works with the royals and develops feelings for one of them. It also has shades of the Hallmark movie "A Christmas Carousel," in which a woman is hired to restore a royal carousel and falls in love with a prince. We're not the only ones that think "Royal Holiday" gives Hallmark vibes either. One Goodreads reviewer stated the same and wrote, "If you like second chance romances and you're looking for a charming little Christmas story to get you in the holiday spirit and put a smile on your face, 'Royal Holiday' is your book."

Where the Heart Is by Billie Letts

"Where the Heart Is" by Billie Letts gives us Hallmark vibes because of its heartwarming storyline with a lost young woman named Novalee Nation who relies on the kindness of strangers in a small southern town. Despite having big dreams, her reality is that she's a pregnant teenager who's all alone with no one to call. Just when she thinks the world looks its bleakest though, the group of well-meaning Oklahomans rally around her and remind her that kindness still exists. Novalee bonds with this eccentric cast of characters, who would be right at home in a Hallmark romp.

"Where the Heart Is" has classic Hallmark community spirit in spades, and we'd recommend it (which was Oprah's Book Club's 22nd pick) to anyone who loves a story set in a spirited small town. That's the premise of various offerings from the channel, particularly holiday movies like "Small Town Christmas" and "Christmas Town." Like us, multiple Goodreads users also got Hallmark feels from "Where the Heart Is" (which was turned into a theatrical movie in 2000), with one writing, "It's basically a Hallmark movie turned into a book. But for a schmaltzy book, I love it and I've read it several times." Or, as Oprah Winfrey put it, "Guaranteed to warm your heart."

Dream State by Eric Puchner

In Eric Puchner's "Dream State," Oprah's Book Club's 111th pick and one of Oprah Book Club picks that give swoon-worthy Valentine's vibes, Cece finds herself falling for Garrett. The problem? Her partner's name is Charlie, and they're about to get married. Even worse? Garrett is Charlie's best friend, who he entrusted to officiate their wedding. This emotional book spans over 50 years by revealing the consequences of Cece's torn heart for her children, who learn the truth about what went on all those years earlier.

There are multiple Hallmark movies featuring the enemies-to-lovers trope, or storylines where a woman has a different partner by the end. You'll devour this book if you enjoyed he likes of Hallmark's "Lucky In Love" and/or "Flip That Romance." Multiple Goodreads users touched on the Hallmark vibes they got from the first half of the book, though they noted the ending was slightly darker than a lot of the channel's movies. As for what Oprah Winfrey thought, she said, "I promise you: It's the kind of book you won't want to put down."

Christmas in London by Anita Hughes

Anne Hughes' "Christmas in London" introduces us to talented New York baker Louisa Graham, who heads to London after receiving an invite to appear on a Christmas Eve episode of a popular television show. While taking in the bright lights of a new city and presenting her sweets to the world, she meets the famous and equally handsome Digby Bunting — and major sparks fly between the two.

"Christmas in London" has all the ingredients for a classic Hallmark movie. A baker who falls in love is a hugely popular trope, and we saw it in "The Secret Ingredient." Baking has also been central to multiple other Hallmark movies, including "A Gingerbread Romance" and "The Baker's Son." Several Goodreads reviewers confirmed the romantic novel reads like a Hallmark movie, while another wrote, "This is a sweet, low-angst, breezy holiday charmer. Go in expecting what it is – basically a Hallmark movie in novel form – and you won't be disappointed."

Go Gentle by Maria Semple

Oprah's Book Club's 122nd pick, "Go Gentle" by Maria Semple, tells Adora Hazzard's story. She's the leader of a group of fabulous older New York women who enjoy regular meetups. But there's a secret they're all keeping, and it'll take more than a good-looking man to get the truth out of them. Enter the mysterious arrival of a handsome stranger who has the potential to change everything, and we're getting Hallmark mystery vibes.

"A whirlwind of secret rendezvous and a new chance at love. It's all about what [Adora Hazzard] is willing to risk. This is one wild ride of a story," Oprah Winfrey said of the book. On Goodreads, one user wrote, "Some intriguing storylines, hallmark quirky characters, and beautiful, lyrical sentences." We'd suggest reading this book if you're a fan of Hallmark's multiple Aurora Teagarden Mystery movies, in which Candace Cameron Bure's librarian Aurora Teagarden teams up with her Real Murders Club group to solve mysteries. Though the "Go Gentle" group is keeping secrets rather than bringing them out into the open, these releases share similar themes, like friendship, secrets, and romance.

Open House by Elizabeth Berg

In Elizabeth Berg's "Open House," protagonist Samantha is forced to rebuild her life after a divorce. Part of her plan includes opening her home to lodgers, which invites some very quirky characters into her building. Samantha, a busy boy mom, takes some wisdom from each of her new friends, all while her own mom attempts to get her back into the dating game. While the novel contains traditional romantic storylines found in countless Hallmark movies, it also focuses on the love Samantha finds for herself as she gets her life back on track under difficult circumstances.

We'd recommend this modern love story, Oprah's Book Club's 38th pick, for those who enjoyed Hallmark's "The Sweeter Side of Life" and "The More Love Grows." Both share a similar plot involving a woman getting back after a divorce, while offering hope to those overhauling their lives after an unexpected life change. Oprah Winfrey shared when recommending the uplifting novel, "So this book is going to ring true to so many people. Anybody, even if you've never divorced but you've ever had a breakup, oh, you're going to see yourself in here."

Tell Me Everything by Elizabeth Strout

Oprah's Book Club's 107th pick, "Tell Me Everything" by Elizabeth Strout, is the fifth in the Amgash series and reintroduces us to the characters from the previous books, including Lucy Barton and Bob Burgess. Lucy's close friend Bob, a lawyer, is engrossed in a murder investigation and confides in Lucy about everything from his work, to his life. And she does the same. Lucy also forges a close bond with the notorious Olive Kitteridge in this installment, and the two bond while swapping their life stories, and the stories of others.

The book may not have the romantic love story that's central to a lot of Hallmark films, but it still gives us plenty of mystery movie vibes. That's partly because the story contains an eerie death to contend with and it's so character driven. The novel, one of the best thriller and mystery picks from Oprah's Book Club, is a must read for Hallmark fans who enjoyed the channel's movies based on platonic relationships, like "Unthinkably Good Things" and "The Santa Summit." "It's a Hallmark movie of a book," confirmed one Goodreads user, while Oprah Winfrey teased of "Tell Me Everything," "[It] has all the things– romance, and mystery and secrets... and even a possible murder."

A Redbird Christmas by Fannie Flagg

"A Redbird Christmas" by Fannie Flagg Deep is set in a small town in Alabama, where big city doctor Oswald T. Campbell finds himself for the holiday season. Oswald becomes enchanted by the traditional, deep south characters he encounters and finds himself equally enthralled by a small bird named Jack. As the holiday season rolls in, Jack plays an important part in a wondrous Christmas miracle that warms Oswald's heart.

"A Redbird Christmas" has an abundance of hope, positivity, and small town charm that we've seen in countless Hallmark movies over the years. It may be missing the classic romance element, but the book is ideal for those who appreciate the channel's uplifting movies with small town, holiday settings. We'd recommend it to fans of the Hallmark movie "November Christmas," in which a community is joined together by Christmas spirit. "If you're in the mood for a Hallmark-movie-type happy endings all around tied up with a bow, this is for you," confirmed one Goodreads user in a five-star review. Another reader gushed, "A fun quick read that is heartwarming and just perfect for this time of year. Think of it as a Hallmark movie in a book."

Starry Night by Debbie Macomber

All journalist Carrie Slayton has to do to get the big promotion she's been dying for is land an interview with rarely seen author Finn Dalton. That's easy, right? Wrong. In Debbie Macomber's "Starry Night," Carrie finally tracks Finn down — but he's in snowy Alaska and its the holidays. Carrie is so desperate to get the scoop for her boss that she travels to him, only to find Finn really doesn't want to open up to her. Carrie really has her work to cut out for her, and she's going to have to pull out all the stops to thaw his heart. "An enjoyable, fluffy holiday romance. Very hallmark movieish," one Goodreads user wrote of the novel. A second wrote in a five-star review, "I absolutely loved this book! It is so well written, and felt as though I were watching a hallmark movie."

Macomber's festive novel has all the elements of a classic Hallmark release. For one, its main character is a journalist, which is one of the genre's most popular professions. On top of that, it's set around the holidays, and features an enemies-to-lovers romance that's the cornerstone of some of the most heartwarming Hallmark movies. "Starry Night" draws particular similarities to Hallmark's "Snow Bride," in which a gossip journalist heads to a small town for a story but finds love instead. It's also similar to Hallmark's "Just My Type," where a woman lands an interview with an elusive author who changes her life. 

How we picked the Oprah's Book Club choices that give Hallmark Channel movie vibes

For this list, we limited our options to picks from Oprah's Book Club or featured on Oprah.com's round-up of the 35 Best Christmas Books to Snuggle up With This Holiday Season. Our definition ofHallmark vibes was any film with a classic romantic, heartwarming, or mystery storyline and a holiday theme (that fit with a stereotypical Hallmark Christmas movie trope). We prioritized books set at least partly in small towns (a staple Hallmark destination) as well as ones that focused on an uplifting story of a woman reclaiming her life after a tough time. When you've read through our picks, check out our roundup of Hallmark Christmas movies for your zodiac sign to continue all the cozy feels.

Recommended