13 Hallmark Channel Mystery Movies Perfect For A Girls' Night In

Add Women on Google:

We may receive a commission on purchases made from links.

You've got the girls over, the wine's flowing, and the snacks are snacking... but what about the movie? Let's be honest, when girls' night rolls around, nothing hits quite like a Hallmark Channel movie. Sure, they're usually not as gritty as the latest dramatic blockbuster or as thought-provoking as an indie Oscar winner. And, yes, we've noticed the odd red flag in Hallmark movies too. But they're easy to watch, you're pretty much guaranteed a happy ending, and they don't demand every second of your attention while you're trying to have fun with your besties. Hallmark's mysteries are particularly perfect for those bestie nights under the blankets, because tuning in to one of the network's whodunnits to see which of you will unravel the mystery first is a surefire way to add some wholesome competition to the night.

Not so sweet, though? Putting your detective hat on to scour Hallmark+ for hours for a movie everyone can agree on. So we've done all the sleuthing for you and compiled 13 Hallmark Channel mystery movies perfect for your next girls' night in. Our choices have strong female protagonists (because that's exactly what we want to see on girls' night) and focus predominantly on female relationships, so we think they'll bring you closer to your girls while making for some interesting (but not too divisive) talking points.

The Mystery Cruise

"The Mystery Cruise," an adaptation of the novel "Santa Cruise: A Holiday Mystery at Sea" by Mary Higgins Clark and Carol Higgins Clark, follows Alvirah Meehan and Regan Reilly as they sleuth at sea.  What would you do if you were playing a murder mystery game on a cruise, only to discover there's a real-life killer in your midst? That's the situation "NYBD Blues" actor Gail O'Grady and "Good Luck Chuck" actor Michelle Harrison's characters face in this Hallmark mystery. With so many people in proximity and nowhere to run, but plenty of places to hide, it's up to the besties to expose the killer before it's too late.

IMDb reviews may not have been overwhelmingly positive for this cruise ship-set murder mystery with period dress aplenty, though one viewer noted it has classic Hallmark vibes and no grisly surprises. That makes it ideal for girls' night in our eyes. An uncomplicated plot allows time to chat with your besties, so you can dip in and out of the movie and grab more snacks without losing track of the storyline. We'd also recommend this movie for those who enjoyed Lifetime's "Cruise Ship Murder," as they share similar themes.

Redemption in Cherry Springs

The fictional town of Cherry Springs is the setting for "Redemption in Cherry Springs" (of course). Our protagonist, Melanie Abrams, played by "White Chicks" actor Rochelle Aytes, uses her journalism skills to get to the bottom of a shocking disappearance in her hometown. It's one of Melanie's childhood friends who has gone missing, which makes this mission deeply personal. We'd recommend this dramatic movie to those looking for the cozy small-town vibes Hallmark does so well, as well as those looking for a mystery led by a determined female protagonist.

In an IMDb review, one watcher noted that, unlike many other Hallmark mysteries, this movie doesn't give away a lot of clues early on. That may give you a little more time to sort the snacks and chat with the girls early on without losing track of the mystery. "Some Hallmark actors can be very wooden but the cast here was excellent. I really enjoyed how it left the ending for a sequel, in fact, I hope Hallmark approves a second movie," read another review.

Nikki & Nora: Sister Sleuths

In "Nikki & Nora: Sister Sleuths," we get a front-row seat to the rocky relationship between fraternal twins Nikki and Nora Sullivan, played by "The Young and the Restless" star Hunter King and "The 100"'s Rhiannon Fish. The sisters have inherited a detective agency together, which sounds like a dream (especially for fans of Hallmark's mysteries). But it starts more like a nightmare for these two, because they've drifted apart over the years and working together is going to be a lot easier said than done. If they're going to solve a murder together, though, they're going to have to find a way to get along. We think this movie is perfect for girls' night, as it may hit home for anyone who's ever had an issue with a sister or close female friend.

"This new Hallmark mystery took me by surprise; I enjoyed it. I liked the storyline brewing between the twins, the animosity between Nora and Detective Sanchez, and the friendship between Nora and police officer Robby Watts," wrote one impressed watcher in their IMDb review. Another pointed out the ending wasn't too obvious, making it a great pick for those looking to do some guessing with their girls.

Aurora Teagarden Mysteries: A Bone to Pick

The Aurora Teagarden Mystery series, which is part of the TV movie collection based on the Aurora Teagarden book series by Charlaine Harris, has proven hugely popular for Hallmark. And we think "Aurora Teagarden Mysteries: A Bone to Pick" is sure to hold the girls' attention. Former "Full House" star Candace Cameron Bure plays Aurora Teagarden (aka Roe) in these mystery movies, and she's on the scent of a murderer here. This mystery is personal for the true crime nut, because her friend Jane has died and left Aurora everything in her will, including a house hiding a grisly secret. Time is ticking for this amateur sleuth to unmask the killer and solve the mystery Jane left behind, so get your guesses in quick.

"Altogether it's a fun movie. Nothing challenging but entertaining," wrote one IMDb user. "I really enjoyed this cozy. If you enjoy mysteries [without] blood & gore, you might too," wrote a second, so it's a solid pick if you want a more PG girlie movie with a little romance to boot. This one also gave us Andie MacDowell Hallmark movie vibes, as she's appeared in several films perfect for a winter day and cocoa.

Aurora Teagarden Mysteries: Reap What You Sew

The second Aurora Teagarden Mystery on our list is "Reap What You Sew." In this installment, Candace Cameron Bure returns as Aurora "Roe" Teagarden, and she's ready to get us guessing along with her again. This time, the character is looking for clues in the murder of sewing enthusiast and businesswoman Poppy Wilson, whom she's known for years.

"Another satisfying Aurora Teagarden mystery that is well-paced, has a simple yet intricately crafted mystery that keeps you glued to the screen – the cast is great as always, especially Lexa Doig," wrote one IMDb reviewer. Another watcher was full of praise for one particularly touching scene between Aurora and her friend Sally, in which Sally vocalizes her support for her amid the grisly investigation. This one may even leave the girls a little teary-eyed and warm and fuzzy at the same time.

Hailey Dean Mysteries: Deadly Estate

Hailey Dean's suspicions are raised when three very odd things happen in close succession in "Hailey Dean Mysteries: Deadly Estate." The man Hailey is dating unexpectedly becomes critically ill, which comes hot on the heels of her friend Pam going missing. To top it off, Pam's boyfriend has a major accident while her disappearance is being investigated. Though bad things come in threes, as the saying goes, Hailey's convinced there may be some foul play going on, and she can't shake the feeling it may all be linked to Pam. The Hailey Dean Mysteries are based on legal commentator and former prosecutor Nancy Grace's novels and star former "ER" actor Kellie Martin as Hailey.

One IMDb user claimed they couldn't guess the villain until they were unmasked, making this a fun movie if you're looking for a harder-to-crack girls' night guessing session. Another suggested it's not as sunny as other Hallmark offerings but wrote, "A less lighthearted mystery but adequate in terms of acting and story."

Hailey Dean Mysteries: Murder, With Love

The Hailey Dean Mysteries movie "Murder, With Love" may have viewers considering the lengths they'd go to in order to protect someone innocent, as Hailey Dean goes to bat for one of her clients. Hailey, a therapist, is convinced her client is innocent when she's questioned by police over the deaths of her parents. With her background as a former prosecutor on her side, she takes it upon herself to clear her client's name by finding out what's really going on.

On IMDb, one user wrote, "Good movie, good cast, interesting mystery, kept me guessing until the end, and when the murderer was identified, I was shocked, did not see that one coming." Perfect, then, if you want to challenge your bestie's mystery-solving skills. A second reviewer highlighted that the movie, which has a strong theme of women supporting women, is very family-friendly. So it could be a good choice if your girls' night includes youngsters.

Garage Sale Mysteries: The Beach Murder

"Garage Sale Mysteries: The Beach Murder," one of the multiple Garage Sale Mysteries movies, sees former "90210" actor and revenge dressing queen Lori Loughlin reprise her role as amateur sleuth Jennifer Shannon. Jennifer puts her passion for the truth to good use when a widow named Annie Winters asks for her help following the death of her husband. His death appears to be an accidental drowning, but Annie refuses to believe her experienced swimmer of a husband wouldn't have been able to keep himself safe in the water. Our protagonist pulls out all the stops to help Annie and bring her the closure she deserves.

In one review shared to IMDb, a reviewer wrote, "This is another great entry in the series...a solid cosy mystery with great family and friendships." Another pointed out a few inaccuracies regarding the location but still shared praise for the plot. "All the little twist and turns and a little clues were great," they said. Ideal for those looking for a Hallmark mystery with strong female relationships and a famous face.

Darrow & Darrow

"Father of the Bride" actor Kimberly Williams-Paisley stars as legal eagle Claire Darrow in the "Darrow & Darrow" movie series. "Darrow & Darrow" is the first movie and sees Claire deal with the ups and downs of family life. That includes butting heads with her mom and fellow lawyer Joanna (played by "Waiting..." star Wendie Malick), who can't help but try to steer her grown-up daughter on everything from her legal practice to her parenting. Amid the friction with her mom, Claire also has a case to solve as she fights to bring justice to a close friend accused of theft.

One IMDb user praised "Darrow & Darrow" for the chemistry between Williams-Paisley's character and her love interest, Tom Cavanagh's Miles Strasberg. Another noted the TV movie contained lighthearted comedy while praising the strong cast, making it a less dramatic, not-too-serious choice for a fun girls' night. A third reviewer shared, "It was fast paced and very funny, almost as if without trying, and it didn't feel like a Hallmark Channel movie, it was better."

Darrow & Darrow: In the Key of Murder

Phoebe is going through a tough time. She's just finished work on her first album, but her ex-producer has turned up dead, and she's the prime suspect. Enter Kimberly Williams-Paisley's Claire Darrow, who's back for more mystery unravelling in "Darrow & Darrow: In the Key of Murder." This continuation of the series is packed with girl power, as Darrow does all she can to clear Phoebe's name. After all, they're almost family now, because Phoebe is the younger half-sister of Miles Strasberg, who's now romantically involved with Claire. There are plenty of cozy scenes between Claire and her man, too.

On IMDb, one watcher shared their hopes for more "Darrow & Darrow" movies. "An excellent choice of actors, quirky and charming. The [storyline] was a good one, interesting little murder mystery to keep you guessing, without taxing the brain cells too much!" they wrote, which sounds ideal for a fun, light night in with the girls. A second praised the on-screen chemistry between Williams-Paisley (one of Hallmark's leading ladies who's stunning without makeup) and Cavanagh."The dialogue in this lively episode is witty and fun, sprinkled with humour that balances the serious topic of the law and murder," they said.

Flower Shop Mysteries: Dearly Depotted

"The Blue Lagoon" actor Brooke Shields and "Matlock"'s Beau Bridges star in Hallmark's Flower Shop Mysteries series, so we'd recommend "Dearly Depotted" for those looking for a cozy story featuring big names. Shields' character Abby Knight is preparing to be a bridesmaid in her cousin's wedding. But even though she left life as a lawyer behind and has since settled into a quieter life as the owner of a flower shop, she realizes crime doesn't take a day off. Her investigative instincts come flooding back when someone is murdered, and it's up to her to investigate.

"This is a nice change for Mystery Lovers who do not want to see all the grit and gore," wrote one IMDb reviewer, adding, "Overall 'feel good' TV movie." That's exactly what we look for in our girls' night movies, and this one fits with the classic Hallmark romance vibe, too, thanks to its wedding setting. Another reviewer enjoyed Shields' on-screen chemistry with Brennan Elliott's character Marco Salvare, writing, "Brooke Shields is brilliant as the protagonist in this light-hearted mystery which plenty of humour and nice banter between the characters. Shields comes across natural and not so OTT as other Hallmark lead actresses. She's part of the charm in this lively mystery."

True Justice: Family Ties

Your brother's just been convicted of a grisly murder. What do you do? In "True Justice: Family Ties," Casey Barlowe (played by "Shadowhunters"' Katherine McNamara) faces that exact scenario. Determined to vindicate her sibling, whom she believes is innocent, Casey enlists the help of her fellow law school classmates and their private investigator friend. Together, they work out a plan to solve the murder and put the actual killer behind bars. This is a guess-inducing Hallmark movie that focuses on the lengths friends and siblings will go to for one another in the name of justice, making it a fun girls' night discussion as the credits roll.

One watcher pointed out in an IMDb review that the cast is a little bigger than in many other Hallmark movies, so there's sure to be a character for everyone to relate to. "[Nikki] DeLoach and her writing partner, Megan McNulty, did a good job with a script that provide twists and turns to keep you guessing," they also wrote. Another praised Alexander Nunez's portrayal of Liam Anderson, the private investigator, who they claimed stole the movie.

The Jane Mysteries: Inheritance Lost

Former "Full House" actor Jodie Sweetin plays Jane DaSilva in "The Jane Mysteries: Inheritance Lost," part of Hallmark's Jane Mysteries series. Jane isn't your average detective. She's putting her skills to good use by seeking justice, not dollars. But her first case makes her realize not everyone is so happy with her sleuthing. The character finds herself in dangerous territory when she investigates a multi-level marketing company that took advantage of her client's mother before her untimely death.

One review was complimentary of Sweetin's acting skills, while also praising the chemistry she shared with Stephen Huszar, who plays Detective John Cameron. "It's standard light mystery bolstered by this chemistry and decent mystery," they said. In another review that was equally complimentary of Sweetin, a watcher stated, "I love that Hallmark has been pumping out mysteries that offer the thinking woman something more than just a cheesy-easy romance. It's fun to follow the clues and try to figure out what happened." That makes this movie a good pick for your night in with the girls, as Jane's mission to uncover buried secrets provides some thought-provoking talking points.

How we decided which Hallmark Channel mystery movies are perfect for a girls' night in

Each of our picks had to have aired on Hallmark Channel or Hallmark Mystery, with mystery as its primary genre. To make sure each movie works for a girls' night, we prioritized movies with female protagonists where female relationships, whether familial or friendships, played a central role. We also took IMDb reviews into account to better understand what viewers enjoyed about each movie and why it could work for your next cozy night in.

Once you've made it through our roundup, why not make girls' movie night a weekly thing? Because we've got plenty of movie recommendations to keep you and your besties entertained. Check out our collection of the best Tyler Hynes Hallmark movies for a girls' night or Andrew Walker's Hallmark movies for a cozy night in front of the TV.

Recommended