Sarah Pidgeon's Hair Evolution Proves She Can Rock Any Look

While some Hollywood figures are nearly unrecognizable without their signature shade, other celebrities manage to pull off both light and dark hair colors. During her relatively short stint in the spotlight, Sarah Pidgeon has quickly proved she ranks among the color chameleons. Not only has the budding star turned heads in rich shades of chestnut, but she's posed in various shades of blond with effortless confidence. 

Pidgeon kickstarted her career appearing in TV shows like "The Wilds" and "Tiny Beautiful Things," even landing a notable role in the reboot of the classic horror movie "I Know What You Did Last Summer." She seemingly stuck to her natural hair color during these early days of her career, telling Into the Gloss the practical reasoning behind her color choice. "I don't want to go to a salon every six weeks for touch-ups," the rising star told the outlet. "I already get haircuts with Megan Robinson at Pearlita every couple of weeks and that's enough."

Pidgeon's big Hollywood breakthrough, though, came in the form of the FX's controversial mini-series "Love Story," which casts the Michigan native in the role of late icon Carolyn Bessette-Kennedy. Not only did the Ryan Murphy-produced project have us picking up the best books about JFK Jr. and Bessette, it also had Pidgeon making the major change from dark brunette to light blonde. In doing so, the budding celeb definitely proved her ability to rock any look. 

Given Sarah Pidgeon's admitted preference for lowkey hair maintenance, it's not surprising that she was sporting a variation of her natural chestnut color long before she started walking the red carpet. A colorized Instagram snapshot shows the star wearing her hair in a shoulder-length style parted in the middle back in 2017, with messy styling complementing the edginess of her classic leather jacket. While there's no caption for context, Pidgeon was studying drama at Carnegie Mellon during this period of her life, seemingly sporting her natural shade throughout this era.

Sarah Pidgeon's natural hair color hit the red carpet in 2023, with the budding star attending events for the hit TV series "Tiny Beautiful Things." At the premiere of the limited series, she wore her tresses around her shoulders with what appears to be a natural wave, going on to shout out her favorite shampoo and conditioner when speaking with Into The Gloss. "I have a bit of a natural curl and wave to my hair, and the Rōz products allow my hair to do its natural thing without getting frizzy," she told the outlet. "They also smell amazing."

By 2025, Sarah Pidgeon had traded in her longer length for a shoulder-skimming cut, parting her still-brunette locks into a middle-part. The rising star showcased the 'do at the trailer launch for "I Know What You Did Last Summer," a movie she appeared in alongside Chase Sui Wonders and Madelyn Cline. The hairstyle still carried a hint of her familiar wave, but mostly looked sleek and professional as Pidgeon posed with her co-stars and participated in onstage discussion. No matter the length, the celeb clearly rocks this rich brunette shade with confidence and ease.

After being cast as Carolyn Bessette-Kennedy in Ryan Murphy's series "Love Story," Sarah Pidgeon stepped out with a striking blond color change. She appeared at the July 2025 premiere of "I Know What You Did Last Summer" with a chunky dye job inspired by Bessette-Kennedy's signature look, which was pioneered by the public figure's colorist Brad Johns. "The transformation took approximately 18 hours in total, spread over two days to ensure the health and integrity of Sarah's hair throughout the process," Pigeon's colorist Kari Hill told Vogue. Additionally, we imagine the new style included some extensions following the celeb's brunette chop.

Sarah Pidgeon rocks more than just a warm-toned chunky blond shade as Carolyn Bessette-Kennedy, as she transitions to a more sleek and uniform style as the series progresses. "The color gets lighter, and the texture disappears, perhaps a reflection of the controlled chaos that surrounded her," stylist Barry Lee Moe told Byride. Pigeon highlighted this change in a polaroid shared to Instagram in February 2026, which shows her sporting a light blond color in a middle-part style. Not only does this entry in the star's evolution demonstrate how far she goes to embody her onscreen character, but it proves her blond versatility.

Sarah Pidgeon continued her blond era during Milan Fashion Week, stepping out at the February 2026 event with her long locks in a honey hue. The half-up hairstyle featuring face-framing pieces marks a distinct entry into the star's color transformation, as it's neither as chunky as her original blond debut, or as uniform as her eventual Carolyn Bessette-Kennedy look. Instead, the rising actor found a solid middle ground with the rich color, ranking among celebrity shades of blond to take to the salon. With Pidgeon's hair evolution in mind, there's no telling what the celeb will try out next.