Hallmark Star Autumn Reeser Can't Stop Making This Makeup Mistake

We may receive a commission on purchases made from links.

Though Hallmark's leading ladies are stunning without makeup, they don't always hit the mark when it comes to beauty routines. So, while Autumn Reeser ranks as a fan-favorite Hallmark star, appearing in made-for-TV movies like "The Wedding Veil Unveiled" and "Junebug," she's also garnered attention for a recurring makeup mistake. The California native has demonstrated a penchant for front-heavy eyebrows on Instagram and occasionally on the red carpet, curating a square-shaped look with thinner arches. As an example, Reeser shared a nature-set selfie with a reflective caption in September 2024, posing in a grassy field while wearing flowy clothing and a wide sunhat.

Though the Hallmark star looks stunning in the simple snapshot, her eyebrows are notably harsher than her scenic surroundings. Eyebrows are sisters and not twins, so it's not surprising that Reeser's arches are a little uneven, but the contrast with the harsh shaping near her inner eye is what really took away from this otherwise subtle look. Unfortunately, blocky brows rank among the common eyebrow mistakes you might be making, with experts marking the technique as majorly unnatural-looking. Though Reeser seemingly can't stop making this beauty error, it admittedly makes the gorgeous star just a little bit more relatable.

While fans may have opinions about Autumn Reeser's harsh eyebrows, that doesn't mean the Hallmark star doesn't have any helpful beauty insights. Back in 2017, the California-born actor revealed an unexpected beauty favorite when speaking to NEW YOU Media. "I'm a big fan of sleep lately," she said, explaining that it wasn't a big priority when she was younger. "I think sleep is really important. I think you need to have the downtime so then you can have enough energy to get through life."

Though Reeser has admitted to not being a huge beauty product person, she has named-dropped some favorites over the years. When speaking to My Skin Affair in 2011, she mentioned Aveeno Positively Radiant Brightening Facial Cleanser and Neutrogena Gentle Oil-Free Eye Makeup Remover as true standouts. "I just really like the Neutrogena line," she explained. "I feel like it's a trustworthy line, you can get it anywhere, it's clean, it's simple, and it's fragrance-free most of the time."

More recently, Reeser shouted out Rose Inc. when working on "'We Met in December," sharing on Instagram that the cruelty-free and vegan company sent makeup products used for the Hallmark movie. "I especially love their lip sculpt color in 'beams,'" she added in the caption. So, while Reeser may be among makeup users called out by the brow blindness TikTok trend, her healthy lifestyle habits and beauty favorites still work in her favor.