5 Kristoffer Polaha Hallmark Movies Perfect For A Snow Day & Cocoa
Kristoffer Polaha has been a familiar face on the Hallmark channel for roughly a decade. He made his Hallmark debut opposite Meghan Markle in "Dater's Handbook" in 2016. Since then, he's starred in more than 20 movies, and even tried his hand at directing. Over the years, fans have come to adore him and the movies he stars in. "If the movie has him in it I am 90% more likely to watch it," wrote one Reddit user. "He is one of my favorites." He's a charming presence on screen and typically has great chemistry with his co-stars. "He's frickin' delicious. He never turns in a bad performance," wrote another Reddit user. "And his voice is like butter melting into your waffles."
It turns out that Polaha loves the world of Hallmark right back, having spoken openly about how much he appreciates the movies, projects, and opportunities that have come his way. "It's been an incredible ride," Polaha told PEOPLE. "It's like a Russian doll: I kept opening up this gift and another gift was inside, and this gift, and it just kept giving." Much like the Andrew Walker Hallmark movies that are perfect for a cozy night in, these Polaha flicks are the perfect way to ignite the holiday spirit.
A Biltmore Christmas
"A Biltmore Christmas" puts a time travel twist on Hallmark romance. Bethany Joy Lenz stars as a screenwriter who is accidentally transported back in time and falls in love with a '40s movie star played by Kristoffer Polaha. This 2023 movie regularly ranks among the best Hallmark holiday movies, with many fans saying it transcends the genre and feels like a modern Christmas classic.
Fans love how it captures the spirit of classic '40s movies. "This is one of their best across the board. I'm a sucker for time travel, love old ['40s] movies, love the Biltmore .... so there was a very good chance I'd like it," wrote one Reddit user. "But they very much exceeded my expectations. It was funny, charming, heart warming, and kept me glued to the screen." Even better, Polaha has sizzling chemistry with Lenz. If you love the glamour of Old Hollywood, then it's the perfect holiday movie to pair with your cocoa on a cold day.
A Dickens of a Holiday!
In "A Dicken's of a Holiday!", Kristoffer Polaha stars as a Hollywood superstar who returns to his hometown to appear in a staging of "A Christmas Carol." Brooke D'Orsay appears across from him as a former classmate-turned-stage director, who retreats to their small town after her Broadway career stalls in New York. But as they work together, sparks quickly begin to fly on-set.
Polaha turns in a wonderful and memorable appearance in this 2021 movie, especially since the play-within-the-movie format gives him lots of opportunities to flex his range as an actor. "I quite liked this one, one of my favorites, not just of the season but, of Hallmark," wrote one Reddit user. "There was real chemistry between the characters and I love it when I can feel that. I could also listen to Polaha talk all day, he needs to do an audiobook like yesterday." If you love Hallmark holiday movies where people leave the big city to revisit their childhood home, then you'll love this sweet small-town tale.
A Grand Ole Opry Christmas
In "A Grand Ole Opry Christmas," the Christmas movie formula gets a major infusion of country music charm — and a little time travel, too. Nikki DeLoach, who has undergone a transformation from Mickey Mouse Club to Hallmark fave, stars as a songwriter who is ready to give up on music. Kristoffer Polaha plays her best friend, who gets whisked back in time along with her. Together they rediscover her passion for music, and find themselves drawn to one another in a new way. There are also plenty of country music celebrity cameos along the way, including Brad Paisley, Megan Moroney, and Rhett Akins.
This 2025 movie isn't just about romantic love; still, Polaha sparkles as the leading man and helps make this movie a charming watch. "I really like Kris P. He could probably have chemistry with a paper sack," wrote one Reddit user. "It was a thoroughly heartwarming movie." If you love Hallmark holiday movies that deal with family bonds in addition to romantic love, or if you're a country music fan, then this is the perfect flick to bring a little warmth to your winter evening.
We Wish You a Married Christmas
Most Hallmark movies end when the happy couple finally gets together. But this unusual take on a love story starts after the happy ending. Kristoffer Polaha and Marisol Nichols star as Robby and Becca, a couple who have become disconnected after years of of marriage. But when they find themselves stranded in a small town over Christmas, they begin finding their way back to one another. It's the perfect wintertime pick if you love any of our favorite second chance romance books.
Nichols and Polaha have sparkling chemistry, and their journey to rediscovering love has charmed viewers since it was released in 2022. Both actors turned in grounded and engaging performances, and the adorable New England setting just adds to the festive vibes. "'We Wish You a Married Christmas' was fabulous and such a refreshing movie for Hallmark," wrote one Reddit user. If you're looking for a Hallmark movie that breaks the mold, then this is the perfect snow day pick.
Hearts of Christmas
This 2016 Hallmark movie casts Kristoffer Polaha as a sort of modern day Scrooge. In "Hearts of Christmas," he plays Matt, the new Chief Financial Officer at a hospital. Emilie Ullerup plays Jenny Miller, a devoted nurse in the Neonatal Intensive Care Unit (NICU), who clashes with Matt over his aggressive cost-cutting measures. But gradually, she helps him to understand the deeper value of the NICU and an unlikely romance begins to blossom between them.
At first blush, this crotchety character feels like a departure from the kind-hearted leading men that Polaha typically plays. But he imbues Matt with unexpected depth, which makes the movie's romantic turn all the more satisfying. "I watched it today and oh my, easily one of my favorites now!" wrote one Reddit user. "If you haven't seen it yet, do watch it! It's very heartwarming and romantic. I think a great example of what Hallmark Christmas movies can be all about." If you like a Hallmark movie with a slightly more dramatic edge, then the romantic drama in "Hearts of Christmas" will satisfy you.