Add These Thriller & Mystery Books To Your TBR If You Love Widow's Bay

We may receive a commission on purchases made from links.

For many, discovering and becoming obsessed with a new TV show is a thrilling escape from the real world that you never want to end. Apple TV's "Widow's Bay" was that show for many viewers in 2026. Therefore, it's no surprise that "Widow's Bay" was given the green light for a second season. The show, which is set in an isolated New England island town bound by strict rules and ancient curses, brings a fresh perspective to the haunted town genre by treating ancient folklore and survival rules with sharp situational humor.

Then, there's the exceptional characters and the standout performances that make the absurd town dynamics land so effectively. There's Mayor Loftis, who is absolutely relentless when it comes to promoting island tourism, regardless of how many ancient entities disrupt the peace, and Sheriff Bechir Clemmons, who brings a practical levelheadedness to island law enforcement, all while supernatural chaos consumes the town. 

If the series has instantly become one of your favorite TV shows and you're also an avid reader looking for a book to hold you over until you can binge more of it, you may be eerily happy to hear there are so many options of thriller and mystery books you can consider adding to your TBR to fill the void. From a story of an island and its people living in a 1994 time loop, to cursed apple orchards and haunted Victorian homes that refuse to be abandoned, fans of "Widow's Bay" will love these books.

"The September House" by Carissa Orlando is an edge-of-your-seat thriller that needs to be added to your TBR if you love the absurd municipal denial and dark humor of "Widow's Bay." 

"The September House" tells the story of Margaret and her perfect dream home, except the perfect dream home is anything but when September rolls around. The house is actually haunted, and while most people would think it's best to leave ... that's not in Margaret's plans. Instead, she decides she'll stay because it's her dream home. So, she and her husband, Hal, begin living amongst the supernatural horrors. Margaret's deadpan determination to stay put no matter what is hauntingly going on around her will strongly remind you of Mayor Loftis and his refusal to let a few ancient entities disrupt island tourism. 

A Goodreads reviewer gave the book five stars and the way they described Margaret will feel all too familiar if you're a "Widow's Bay" fan, "Her subtle humor as she dealt with everything in this haunted house had me laugh out loud numerous times." If you loved watching characters casually go about their day-to-day lives while avoiding death and treating hauntings like minor nuisances, Margaret's unfazed stubbornness will be right up your alley. 

If you became a "Widow's Bay" fan because of the isolated island atmosphere, strict community survival rules, and ancient local lore, Jimmy Juliano's "Dead Eleven" needs to be the next book on your TBR. This book has horror, mystery, and all of the elements that make small town life feel suffocating. Juliano executes this unsettling story by blending eerie nostalgia with an unease that lingers.

This uncanny thriller transports readers to Clifford Island. While that sounds ideal, everyone on the island must live under one non-negotiable mandate: every single day must be lived as if it were 1994. There's no modern tech allowed, retro fashion is a must, and residents perform rigid daily rituals to appease a sinister entity that is bound to the island's soil. Yes, we know, it exudes "Widow's Bay" energy, and it only gets better from there. Similar to the delicate balance of civic order and supernatural threat maintained by Sheriff Clemmons and Mayor Loftis, the islanders treat their outlandish, time-locked existence as a necessary sacrifice for survival. 

A four star Goodreads reviewer said, "Fans of 'Widow's Bay' — this one is for you. We have a mysterious island that appears stopped in time, a secretive past, a history of people who have completely disappeared, and a tendency for islanders to stay ... forever ..." 

Fans of "Widow's Bay" will agree that Mayor Loftis carried the show. His somewhat ridiculous obsession with boosting island tourism, no matter how thoroughly and clearly the island was haunted, made for peak dark comedy. If that desperate drive to turn a blind eye to obvious danger was your favorite element of the show, Chuck Wendig's "Black River Orchard" is a must read.  

Dan is a farmer struggling to make ends meet in a town that is also struggling. Then, he stumbles upon a rare heirloom apple tree on his family's land. Dan believes the apple tree is the key to saving his family farm, so he cultivates the fruit and the miraculous harvest transforms his failing town's fortunes overnight. However, there are blatant signs of supernatural doom, but of course, the hungry farmer ignores them, just like Mayor Loftis ignoring ancient threats for tourist dollars. This book is a dark tale of what happens when greed consumes a small town. 

A reviewer gave the book two thumbs up and five stars (via Goodreads), noting, "Who knew 500+ pages of evil apples in a small town could be so disturbing, disgusting and downright a**-kicking? This was a blast!" You know how the people of "Widow's Bay" continued to make one bad decision after another? Well, the residents of this small town have the exact same destructive logic and just run with it. 

The next book on this list is "Hex" by Thomas Olde Heuvelt, and it's a terrifying read that proves small towns will do anything to keep an ancient curse quiet. While the premise sounds somewhat like "Widow's Bay," there is very little humor in this deeply dark and claustrophobic thriller. So, if your favorite part of "Widow's Bay" is the dry, absurd satire of municipal bureaucracy, you may want to skip this book. However, if you enjoy the eerie tension of an isolated town bound by strict rules to survive a curse, then "Hex" will be one of the best psychological thrillers you read on Kindle Unlimited. 

When a 17th century witch tries to overtake the picturesque town of Black Spring, the local residents have no plans of leaving. Instead, they decide to manage her presence with high tech surveillance and rigid protocol. Tracking her via smartphone apps and enforcing strict quarantine laws, the townspeople will do anything to ensure outsiders never know their secret. This story is full of relentless dread and psychological paranoia. 

Although many fans of "Widow's Bay" have compared it to "Hex," this is a book that readers say is either a love or hate. Some praise its chilling concept, while others find Heuvelt's prose bizarre. But, if you are in the spirit for something creepy, this pick is for you. A five star reviewer said, "Hands down the creepiest book I have ever read ... When a book genuinely disturbs you, you know you are onto a good thing."

"Scuttler's Cove" by David Barnett was a book that came up quite often when readers asked for book recommendations that were similar to "Widow's Bay," and once you read the premise of the story it's not hard to see why. A coastal village, a haunting, and an isolated community with too many secrets for their own good that they've kept buried for generations just to protect their peaceful seaside town. All of that is completely disrupted by wealthy out of townies who begin buying up properties and end up unearthing the ancient entity buried deep beneath the cove. 

Barnett takes the elements that made "Widow's Bay" so addictive, but strips the humor and replaces it with raw, unending dread. There is no satirical wit to balance the looming threat here, instead, this story dives into gruesome horror that keeps you on the edge of your seat wondering what terrifying thing is going to happen next. 

An Amazon reviewer gave the book five stars and described the book as being "pitch-perfect folk horror for our modern world." They also added, "The dangers of both the new and old collide in this story that explores the dark cycles that span generations, and what it could take to break them. This book is mysterious and creepy and wonderfully atmospheric." If you're open to skipping the laughs to lighten the mood when a town is haunted, then this dark coastal nightmare is perfect for your fall TBR.

Lastly, we have "The Memory Police" by Yoko Ogawa. Compared to the other lengthier books on the list, this one may be considered a short mystery & thriller book you can read in one day, especially if you're a speedy reader. This is another book that delves into the absurdities of an isolated small town without any humor, opting instead for a quiet, deeply melancholic atmosphere. 

In Japan, there's a nameless island where the residents deal with the unpredictable disappearances of everyday objects ordered by the government. Oddly enough, the residents are more than willing to surrender their belongings. That is until their minds physically purge all memory of what was lost. This will be a sinister read that will have you asking yourself just how far an isolated community will go to conform when state power decides what can and cannot exist. 

If the unsettling mandates that were followed without question in "Widow's Bay" were the draw for you, Ogawa's story will have you captivated by its haunting exploration of enforced compliance, showing the devastating emotional toll of a town that surrenders its past just to survive. Our writer is a fan of this author and read this book in one sitting. As she watched "Widow's Bay," she was instantly reminded of "The Memory Police," and knew this had to be a pick on a reading list for "Widow's Bay" fans. 

It's easy to pinpoint what you love about a certain TV show or book, but it's not easy searching for those elements in your next read or watch. When looking for books similar to Apple TV's "Widow's Bay," standard mystery tropes or even island thrillers won't cut it. There are so many books set on an island where someone goes missing or a body washes ashore, but "Widow's Bay" hits a very specific, uncanny nerve. It's not just about being on an island; it's about being trapped in a small town where the rules are bizarre and the people are strange ... Often looking the other way just to keep the peace. 

For curating a list of books similar to "Widow's Bay," our writer had one specific book in mind, which was "The Memory Police," but obviously one title isn't enough to build a hearty list for our readers. That's when we turned to Reddit. First, we searched communities dedicated to "Widow's Bay" and books, because we knew book lovers would be in search of a read that would fill the void just as much as we were. This helped us gather a number of potential titles for this list before narrowing them down based on our criteria. 

We vetted each title through reviews on Amazon and Goodreads. Instead of solely relying on star ratings, we did a deep dive into detailed reviews to verify that each book genuinely captured that specific, lingering sense of dread the hit show executed so well.