Pics Of The Leading Ladies Of Sabrina The Teenage Witch, Then & Now

"Sabrina The Teenage Witch" became an instant hit when it debuted in 1996. The kids' show, about a teenager who discovers she's a witch, aired for seven seasons and gave us iconic '90s fashion and some epic one-liners from Sabrina's talking cat, Salem Saberhagen. It also made big names of some of its leading ladies, with the likes of Melissa Joan Hart, Soleil Moon Frye, and Caroline Rhea carving out impressive careers afterward. There must have been some serious magic on this set though, because the cast of the supernatural series look just as gorgeous today as they did during its heyday.

Side by side pics of the female cast then and now prove they aren't '90s actors who look totally unrecognizable, as so many still look just like their characters — despite decades passing since the show made its debut. In fact, fans were taken aback by how ageless the cast looked when they reunited in 2018 for the show's 15th anniversary. "Melissa Joan Hart is actually a witch, she hasn't aged in 15 years ugh," one X user wrote. Another tweeted after seeing Caroline Rhea and Beth Broderick reprise their roles as Aunt Hilda and Aunt Zelda in Netflix's "Chilling Adventures of Sabrina" in 2020, "I wanna know how the aunts from the OG 'Sabrina The Teenage Witch' haven't aged at all after all these years." And they're in good company when it comes to maturing like fine wine.

Melissa Joan Hart has barely aged since playing Sabrina Spellman. At the 2026 Kentucky Derby (which was full of fashion flops), she proved she's still rocking Sabrina's signature blond hair, though she'd gone a little lighter. Her glam was a little heavier than when she was younger too, including fluttery, long, faux eyelashes and full coverage foundation. Despite looking exactly as we'd expect Sabrina to look as she entered her 50s, Hart told Entertainment Weekly in 2024 she never really identified with her character.

Caroline Rhea played Hilda Spellman, Sabrina Spellman's aunt who loved to have fun and shank responsibility, on "Sabrina The Teenage Witch." At the 2025 Project Angel Food's Angel Awards, the actor proved she still had Hilda's mischievous grin and blond locks, which she wore long in a youthful, loose ponytail. Though almost 30 years had passed since she debuted the character, Rhea was still recognizable as Sabrina's kooky caregiver at 61 and was still having fun with makeup via her pink lipstick and fluttery lashes.

As Sabrina Spellman's strait-laced aunt, Beth Broderick's Zelda Spellman was all about responsibility and rules, which was demonstrated via her sensible shorter haircut. In real life though, Broderick has a more undone look, which she showed off at the 2025 Ed Asner and Friends Celebrity Poker Tournament. The actor had seemingly embraced her graying natural hair and wore her hair a little shorter than in some "Sabrina" episodes. The star was 66 at the time but still had plumped, youthful skin as she flashed a smile.

Jenna Leigh Green appeared in multiple episodes of "Sabrina The Teenage Witch" as Sabrina Spellman's high school nemesis Libby Chessler. In the show, the popular character rocked long brown hair, which was still part of her signature look at a 2026 screening of the movie "Influenced." The star, who was 48 in the snap, had glowy skin and a few relatable fine lines around her eyes and forehead, which contributed to her down-to-earth beauty.

Lindsay Sloane played Sabrina Spellman's high school best friend Valerie Birkhead. She also gained notoriety via the likes of the 2000 cheerleader movie "Bring It On" and an appearance in the comedy "Horrible Bosses 2." She was spotted at a Hugo Boss event in 2019, still sporting the fair skin and dark brunette hair her "Sabrina The Teenage Witch" character had. Sloane was 42 at the time and proved she had a fun, quirky side like Valerie via her multiple ear piercings on both sides.

Soleil Moon Frye joined the cast of "Sabrina The Teenage Witch" as Sabrina Spellman's college roommate Roxie King. The star, who also famously played the lead role in "Punky Brewster," had a few more lines on her face than when she appeared in the comedy (and, really, who hasn't?). She still sported Roxie's long, straight, rich brown hair at 49 for a screening of "The Carters" in 2025, proving she's barely changed since she made her "Sabrina" debut in 2000. And it's still working for her.

Elisa Donovan also began appearing in "Sabrina The Teenage Witch" when Sabrina Spellman went off to college. Elisa Donovan played the ditzy Morgan Cavanaugh, who was instantly recognizable thanks to her long red hair. At the premiere of the Michael Jackson movie "Michael" in 2026, the actor still sported Morgan's fiery, curly locks, but opted for a more vivid shade that brought warmth to her skin. She also proved she hadn't lost her youthful megawatt smile at 55.