May 2026 New Releases You'll Want To Pick Up For Your Book Club

We may receive a commission on purchases made from links.

April showers might bring May flowers, but the publishing industry is bringing an exciting slate of titles to your local bookstore. As we cast off the last shackles of the school year and transition to warmer months, we leave behind all things cozy and/or academic, at least if the new release rosters are anything to go by. Summer romances and celebrity memoirs overwhelm the landscape as we gear up for a season of beach reads, but one surprising trend among the May 2026 releases is alien-themed stories. Anticipation of the Artemis II excitement, perhaps?

When it comes to your book club, however, these genres have drawbacks. A story too light and fluffy will give you nothing to talk about, but if you choose something too complex or out there, you risk losing some folks. Fortunately, the new releases of May 2026 are full of authors with proven book club track records, relatable themes, and stories that strike just the right balance between riveting and riverside.

Elizabeth Strout is a book club titan, having been chosen by Oprah's Book Club not once but twice, for 2019's "Olive, Again" (the sequel to Pulitzer Prize winner "Olive Kitteridge") and 2024's "Tell Me Everything." It's easy to see why: Strout's stories of ordinary people grappling with the meaning of their lives in small-town coastal Maine make for poignant page-turners.

That's sure to be the case for "The Things We Never Say," too. Readers will see all too much of themselves in Artie Dam, a husband, father, and high school history teacher who goes along to get along while silently resenting a political landscape gone mad and humanity's increasing isolation from itself. Reflecting on the events that wake Artie up from his stupor — a life-threatening accident and a family-threatening revelation — as well as his beliefs that 'to say anything real [is] to say things that nobody want[s] to know' will provide book club members with plenty to talk about.

If you were spellbound by Matt Haig's "The Midnight Library," you're not alone. The runaway bestseller became a book club staple, including the Good Morning America Book Club, thanks to the intriguing question at its center: What if there was a library where you could pick up a book and be transported to a version of your life where you had made different choices? The result was a tale of regret, frustration, and ultimately hope that provoked both thoughts and tongues.

That's why you'll want your book club to be one of the first to read the book's sequel, "The Midnight Train," which asks a slightly different but equally compelling question: What if you could go back to any point of your life? Would you simply revisit your favorite moments, or would you do things differently, even if change would bring far-reaching consequences? Not a single member of your book club is 100% confident in their decisions, so they'll be enthralled by Wilbur's quest to get the love of his life back, if only for a quick stop.

For thriller readers, the release of a new Gillian McAllister title is a holiday in and of itself, but "Caller Unknown" will also arrive just in time for Mother's Day. That ties in nicely with the plot, which concerns a mother whose teenage daughter is kidnapped from their Texas vacation rental. She soon learns that it's not money the kidnapper wants; they've got a job for her. One that would put her in grave danger, but to refuse would put her daughter in danger of the grave.

McAllister skyrocketed to stardom thanks in part to the Richard & Judy Book Club, which selected "That Night" in 2021, and even larger part to the Reese's Book Club selection of her most successful novel, "Wrong Place, Wrong Time." She hasn't had a flop since, so "Caller Unknown" is certain to be another knockout book club pick. (It's even rumored to be the May 2026 Read With Jenna selection.) Members will come for the pulse-pounding action that lands somewhere between "Taken" and "Narcos" and stay for the meditation on their own relationships with their mothers and/or children.

If the name Katheryn Stockett sounds only vaguely familiar, it's not because her work is forgettable. Her blockbuster debut, 2009's "The Help," became both a Hollywood hit and a wildly popular book club selection. Since then, however, Stockett has given us all but radio silence. Until now, that is. Her follow-up effort, "The Calamity Club," might have taken nearly 20 years to hit the shelves, but it promises to be no less discussion-worthy.

Although it takes place almost 100 years ago in Depression-era Mississippi, the struggles of the members of "The Calamity Club" are just as relevant to women today. Charlie, Birdie, and 11-year-old Meg have each been beaten down by a cruel world of economic insecurity and gender oppression, and their only way out might be to join forces in a desperate scheme to declare their independence. Will it be worth it? Only your book club can decide.

If you think your book club might be receptive to dipping their toes in the waters of extraterrestrial fiction, there's no better entry point than "Take Me With You" by Steven Rowley. You already know him from his bestselling "The Guncle" series and 2023's Read With Jenna pick, "The Celebrants." Now, he's back with another story of love and family, which is offbeat to say the least.

In "Take Me With You," college professor Jesse del Ruth's life is turned upside down in an instant when his husband and partner of 30 years, Norman, walks into their backyard one night and into an otherworldly beam of light, vanishing without a trace. For the first time in his adult life, Jesse is alone, and he doesn't know what that means. Your book club members may not have ever lost someone to aliens (bonus if they have!), but they'll all relate to Jesse's experiences of abandonment, indecision, and indignation at this world and beyond. The Joshua Tree setting doesn't hurt, either. Hey, it's vacation season.

Debut authors don't get a lot of book club love. Sometimes, it's just too risky to take a chance on an unknown name. Shannon Garvey's "June Baby," however, comes with cred to spare. It's part of Jenna Bush Hager's "Thousand Voices" project, dedicated to nurturing debut authors at Random House through the publishing process. A previous release, "Into the Blue" by Emma Brodie, was the April 2026 Reese's Book Club pick. No less a book club heavyweight than Elin Hilderbrand, the "Queen of Beach Reads" herself, has declared "June Baby" the "book of the summer."

But despite the New England island setting, "June Baby" is no breezy read. It's about Ruth, a woman for whom Block Island became a second summer home as a teenager after the death of her mother, though Ruth doesn't fit in with the wealthy tourists who flock to the island. She's more of an intermittent townie, eking out a living and hopefully some writing during her annual return. This year, however, her life is upended by tragedy once more, and her quest to understand her past and compose her own future ensures it's one to remember. The powerful narrative set against the waves of the Atlantic means "June Baby" is a book you'll want to read on vacation and keep thinking (and talking) about long after you get home.