Which Husband Gave Christina Haack Her Priciest Engagement Ring?

Christina Haack tends to collect engagement rings like Tom Brady collects Super Bowl rings. The HGTV star has been engaged three times, first famously tying the knot with her "Flip or Flop" co-star Tarek El Moussa in 2009. They split in 2016, though, three years before she walked down the aisle with British TV star Ant Anstead. Then there was her marriage to Josh Hall, which lasted from 2022 until 2025, and saw Haack dress for revenge after their divorce. But which husband gave her the priciest engagement ring?

Hall seemingly bestowed the reality star with the priciest rock. That ring came courtesy of Benny and the Gems (Haack gave the brand a shoutout on Instagram Stories while confirming her engagement), and jeweler Benny Hayoun told E! News the custom, 5-carat rock was estimated to be worth $200,000. "[Hall] knew exactly what she wanted. He was confident and wanted to pick the best ring he could," Hayoun said. Mike Fried, CEO of The Diamond Pro, priced the stunning piece slightly lower, though. "Christina's pavé engagement ring represents exquisite beauty and class. Her enormous diamond is 5 carats and looks to be worth $150,000," he told Hello!. "Her square shape diamond appears to be a radiant cut and her band is lined with smaller diamonds that accentuate the center stone," he added.

El Moussa hasn't shared publicly how much he dropped on Haack's first engagement ring, but it's unlikely he spent near the $200,000 estimate of her third. The two were yet to see success with "Flip or Flop" when they married, and Haack admitted they didn't have a lot of disposable income when HGTV came knocking. "They liked the fact that we were poor and were trying to make something of ourselves," she told The Orange County Register.

It's not clear if "Wheelers Dealers" host Ant Anstead popped the question to Christina Haack with a traditional engagement ring, as she only seemed to wear her wedding band in photos and videos. However, we know the couple showed their love via very blingy jewelry at their nuptials. People confirmed they got rings from Randall Scott Fine Jewelry & Watches, which included an 8.5-carat eternity ring for Haack. The stunning piece featured a whopping 16 diamonds on a platinum band, and TMZ reported the "Christina On The Coast" star kept the pricey piece following her and Anstead's divorce (as well as two expensive cars).

Haack isn't the only one with an affinity for fancy jewelry, though, as her passion for sparkly accessories appears to have been inherited by her and El Moussa's daughter, Taylor El Moussa. In 2024, the reality star revealed on Instagram Stories that she'd bought the teen a gold Cartier Love bracelet for her 14th birthday. "An iconic gift she will have forever. Grateful I can do that for her," Haack wrote (via People). The classic version of the iconic bracelet retails for $7,350.

As for Haack adding another engagement ring to her collection, she has teased a potential need for some stunning wedding manicure inspo. "Okay, well ... maybe one more [marriage]," she said on Radio Andy in March 2025, teasing she might change her last name for a fourth time (via People).