11 Amish Romance Novels That Have A Huge Fan Following

SoSo, history, look, angry, Amish
'Witness' via Paramount Pictures

What happens on Rumspringa, stays on Rumspringa!

Try Reading Something New With These 11 Amish Romance Novels

The Amish community is not necessarily one that people know much about. There are lots of television shows about the Amish which gives some insight into the culture but the popularity of Amish romance novels is outstanding. Clearly, there's a huge fandom and for good reason.

The Christian community might find Amish romance novels more appropriate for the genre as most are clean and wholesome.

If you're looking for less sex, raunchy characters, and risqué behavior then you'll probably love reading Amish romance novels. Learn more about some of the best ones, below!


Want to write your own Amish romance novel? Read about our submission process, here and you could be published on Women.com!

1. The Amish Inn

via Amazon

Buy on Amazon.

Escape away to The Amish Inn! Eve Wengerd must keep her bed and breakfast after the terrible death of her husband. As a single mother she must go up against the loan officer, Mason Raber, who is adamant about collecting her final payment. But this is a romance novel so don't you worry, they might find love...

2. Amish Acres

via Amazon

Buy on Amazon.

Who knew celery would be so romantic? Not me... I'm allergic. Naomi's land is a hot commodity now that a celery patch popped up overnight (I'm not making this up) but mean rumors swirl that she did it for attention. Will her land and heart ever be protected? You better start reading to find out.

3. The Hope Jar

via Amazon

Buy on Amazon.

Wanda E. Brunstetter is one of the most successful Amish romance novelists of all time. Michelle Taylor isn't who she seems to be but she's grown to love her Amish family. When she finds a jar containing quotes, thoughts, and prayers, she falls even more in love with her faith.

4. The Teacher's Bride

via Amazon

Buy on Amazon.

Christian Ropp is not a fan of chaos. His life doesn't contain it and his classroom certainly is void of such recklessness. But he's shocked to find his attraction to Ruby Glick, a woman who is synonymous with chaos. But he's tasked with getting the students of the Birch Creek school in order, while also trying to find a wife. Bestselling Amish romance author, Kathleen Fuller will captivate you in The Teacher's Bride.

5. An Unforgivable Secret

via Amazon

Buy on Amazon.

Hannah has a blessed life, from her home to her husband, to the Amish community she loves, she's aware of her good life. But a secret she's been carrying an easy thing to carry. That very secret might be the thing that takes away everything she loves.

6. The Thorn

via Amazon

Buy on Amazon.

Beverly Lewis is a beloved Amish romance author and you'll know why when you read The Thorn. Travel to Amish country and meet sisters, Rose and Hen, two opposite personalities in the same community. Love, religion, and culture are major themes of this popular book!

7. Winter Wheat

via Amazon

Buy on Amazon.

Lena Graber will do anything to keep her farm, even let Jacob King plant seeds. After her husband died her mother-in-law hasn't stopped bothering her with a debt she can't fulfill. She needs space to herself and lives with her aunt and uncle in Pennsylvania Amish country. The community is vastly different than hers in New York; she can wear color and ride in cars. Her new life seems more exciting than the one waiting back at home but will she leave Jacob alone or pave her own path?

8. With Winter's First Frost

via Amazon

Buy on Amazon.

Laura Kauffman and Zechariah Stutzman aren't getting any younger. At age seventy-three their ailments are greater than their strengths but when they realize their love for one another, they might just have a second chance.

9. A Seat by the Hearth

via Amazon

Buy on Amazon.

Priscilla must go back to back to a community she left behind but this time, with her six-year-old son. She needs to be reintroduced to her family even though she's feeling suffocated yet again. She must agree to their Amish rules which means marrying inside the community. But when the playboy next door catches her attention she might care more about love than the secrets of her past.

10. Seasons of an Amish Garden

via Amazon

Buy on Amazon.

A garden is erected for a friend in this delightfully clean Amish romance novel. Learn all about the Seasons of an Amish Garden and maybe you'll be inspired to plant flowers of your own.

11. The Amish Deacon's Daughter

via Amazon

Buy on Amazon.

Amy is set to marry someone she's never met and he's not even in her town. A long-distance relationship, a sister who marries first, and love that seems like a fleeting moment, you'll love reading The Amish Deacon's Daughter.

Let's Keep the Conversation Going...

What's your favorite Amish romance novel? We want to know!

Tweet us @womendotcom or follow us on Facebook and Instagram!

We hope you love the products we recommend! Before you continue, we’d like you to know that there are affiliate links in this article. This means Women.com may collect a share of sales or other compensation from the following links. Prices are accurate and items are in stock as of time of publication.